1993

The Third Controller

Hiromichi Tanaka — The producer whose name sits in small letters, and who once admitted he had doubts about the best-loved part of his game.

August 1993 — Tokyo, Square

On August 6, 1993, Square released Secret of Mana in Japan. It was a game about three people walking through a world together. It had begun as a game about one.

Hiromichi Tanaka was the producer, and he is also credited with the scenario. He was born in 1962 and had been at Square since 1983, when he left Yokohama National University to follow his classmate Hironobu Sakaguchi into a new software branch. Koichi Ishii directed and designed the game. Tanaka's name appears in the credits the way a producer's name usually does: present, and not loud.

The game did not start where it ended. By Tanaka's own account, the project was once meant to be Final Fantasy IV, then became a separate project under the codename Chrono Trigger, and finally became Seiken Densetsu 2. Other accounts say it was first planned for the Super Famicom CD-ROM add-on, and that the cartridge version had to be cut down. Ishii has estimated that as much as forty percent of what was planned was dropped (sources differ on the exact figure).

In 1993, Hippon Super magazine sat Tanaka and Ishii down together. Tanaka was asked about the things left out. He answered in one plain line: "There were a lot of things in this game that we wanted to add but couldn't." He did not say what they were, and he did not say he was sorry.

He was more specific about the companions. The plan, he said, had been a one-player game, with two companions controlled by the computer. Then came the part that fills the rest of this page: "it seemed kind of boring to just let your two companions be controlled by the computer AI." So the team let other people take those two seats.

Ishii called it "a kind of bonus thing we added in." It was not a pillar of the design. It was an addition, made because the alternative felt dull, and it is what a great many players remember first. A second person could pick up a controller and join in the middle of the walk, and a third could join after that.

The computer companions were not neglected. Tanaka said one person worked on the allies' behavior exclusively, for almost two years. Two years of work on characters whose most memorable job, for some players, was to be replaced by a friend.

The ring menu shows the same habit. Instead of a list, the game opens a circle of icons around the hero. Tanaka told the interviewer: "When we were first designing it though, I had my doubts." He had thought it would be cumbersome until players got used to it. Then he added that once you do, it is "definitely quick and easy." A producer reporting, in a magazine, that he had doubted one of his own best ideas is rare enough to notice.

Tanaka's later years are better known for larger and louder events, and the museum tells those elsewhere. This is the smaller record. A deadline, a format change, a list of things that did not fit, and one decision to let a friend sit where a program had been.

Think of the part of your own work that people thank you for most. Did you plan it, or did you add it because the plain version seemed boring?

削られた後に残る物退屈への小さな抵抗自分の案を疑える強さ

This story features

Games in this story

Each title below has its own page — history, trivia, and collector's notes.

Super Famicom / SNES · 1993

Secret of Mana

Three players, one cartridge, one cable. A ring menu system copied everywhere. A soundtrac…

Game Boy · 1991

Final Fantasy Adventure

He borrowed a famous name to get through the door — and built an entirely different world …

Read next

Sources

  1. Secret of Mana — Hippon Super interview with Koichi Ishii and Hiromichi Tanaka (1993) — Shmuplations — accessed 2026-11-14
  2. Secret of Mana — Wikipedia (English) — accessed 2026-11-14
  3. Hiromichi Tanaka — Wikipedia (English) — accessed 2026-11-14

This museum is run by Enjoy Game Japan, a retro game shop in Japan.